from 01.01.1991 until now
Ekaterinburg, Ekaterinburg, Russian Federation
Ufa, Russian Federation
Birsk, Ufa, Russian Federation
Ufa, Russian Federation
VAK Russia 5.2.1
VAK Russia 5.2.4
VAK Russia 5.2.5
VAK Russia 5.2.6
VAK Russia 5.2.7
UDC 17.03
UDC 330.8
This article explores bioethics as a multidimensional phenomenon, existing in a global context but rooted in interdisciplinarity and philosophical reflection. The authors' analysis provides a foundation for understanding the role of bioethics in responding to global challenges such as pandemics and rapid technological advances, which further advances its relevance as a platform for dialogue and substantiates the current theoretical and methodological shift. This study analyzes two different approaches to understanding the genesis and essence of bioethics, revealing a key theoretical and methodological shift in its development. On the one hand, there is a local, or technocratic, approach, which developed as a response to specific biomedical challenges (from medical scandals to technological breakthroughs) within specific cultural and legal traditions. On the other hand, there is a universalist, pluralistic model that interprets bioethics as a global project, normatively grounded in the human rights system and responding to universal challenges. Based on a comparison of socio-cultural characteristics, historical conditions and practices in the USA and Russia, the unique contribution of the Russian school is formulated. The relevance of this study is determined, on the one hand, by the need for a systematic comparative analysis of Western and Russian bioethical paradigms, and on the other, by the need to identify the heuristic potential of the domestic model for addressing global health issues. The aim of this article is to reconstruct the main conceptual approaches to understanding the genesis, theoretical content, and sociocultural foundations of bioethics in the West and Russia, and to demonstrate that their mutual enrichment leads to the formation of a more sustainable and universal system of bioethical regulation adequate to the complexity of the modern era.
bioethics, biomedical ethics, medical experiments, global challenges, biomedical technologies, epidemics, pandemics
1. Bel'montskiy doklad. Eticheskie principy i rukovodyaschie ukazaniya po zaschite prav cheloveka v issledovaniyah. 1979. - URL: http://www.bioethics.ru/rus/library/id/388/ (data obrascheniya: 02.03.2026).
2. Zil'ber A.P. Etyudy medicinskogo prava i etiki / A.P. Zil'ber. – M.: MEDpress-inform, 2022. - 840 s.
3. Zil'ber A.P. Medicinskaya etika, deontologiya ili utilitarizm? / A.P. Zil'ber. - Petrozavodsk: PetrGU, 2015. - 95 s.
4. Ivanyushkin A.Ya. Vrachebnaya etika v Rossii (XIX - nachalo XX v.). V kn.: Bioetika: principy, pravila, problemy / A.Ya. Ivanyushkin. – M.: Editorial URSS, 1998. - S. 93-110.
5. Kubar' O.I. Rol' Rossii v istorii i sovremennom razvitii eticheskoy koncepcii v biologii i medicine / O.I. Kubar' // Bioetika. - №1. 2011 (7) - S. 13-15.
6. Mihel' I.V. Bioetika v kontekste istorii: filosofskie issledovaniya bioeticheskogo dvizheniya: monografiya / I.V. Mihel'. - Saratov: Sarat. gos. tehn. un-t, 2015. - 248 s.
7. Moiseev N.N. Byt' ili ne byt'… chelovechestvu? / N.N. Moiseev. – M.: Ul'yanovskiy Dom pechati, 1999. – 288 s.
8. Moiseev N.N. Modeli ekologii i evolyucii / N.N. Moiseev. – M.: Znanie, 1983. - 64 s.
9. Potter V.R. Bioetika: most v buduschee. Pod red. S.V. Vekovshininoy, V.L. Kulinichenko / V.R. Potter. - Kiev: Izdatel' Karpenko, 2002. - 216 s.
10. Sadikova O.S. Russkiy kosmizm kak predtecha global'noy bioetiki / O.S. Sadikova // Saharovskie chteniya 2019 goda: materialy 19-y mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferencii. - Minsk: IVC Minfina, 2019. - Ch. 3. - S. 490–493.
11. Siluyanova I.V. Bioetika v Rossii: cennosti i zakony/ I.V. Siluyanova. – M.: Grant', 2001. – 192 s.
12. Sokolov V.M. Ocenka povedencheskih faktorov riska medicinskih rabotnikov v usloviyah epidemiy i ekstremal'nyh situaciy / V.M. Sokolov, A.V. Stovba // Sovremennye issledovaniya social'nyh problem. - Tom 12. - № 2 (2020). – S. 68-83. - URL: http://journal-s.org/index.php/mrsp/index (data obrascheniya: 02.03.2026).
13. Sokolov V.M. Imperativnost' bioeticheskogo podhoda k moral'no-politicheskim problemam koronakrizisa KOVID -19 / V.M. Sokolov, A.V. Stovba // Gumanitarnyy vektor. - 2021. - T. 16. - № 2. - S. 80-87.
14. Sovershenstvovanie institucional'noy infrastruktury APK: voprosy teorii i praktiki : monografiya / A.N. Semin, M.M. Kislickiy, A.S. Lylov, V.Yu. Vorona. – M.: KOL LOK, 2023. 360 s. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/CYVLVS.
15. Teoriya, metodologiya i praktika realizacii ekvivalentnyh mezhotraslevyh otnosheniy v APK : monografiya / O.A. Rodionova, A.S. Truba, L.A. Golovina, M.M. Kislickiy, O.A. Greben'kova, O.T. Kopytina, O.V. Logacheva, T.G. Evsyukova; Pod. red. prof. O.A. Rodionovoy. – M.: Fond razvitiya i podderzhki molodezhi «Kadrovyy rezerv», 2019. 220 s. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/KMMKMM.
16. Tischenko P.D. Bio-vlast' v epohu biotehnologiy / P.D. Tischenko. – M.: IF RAN, 2001. -182 s.
17. Frolov I.T. Etika nauki: Problemy i diskussii / I.T. Frolov, B.G. Yudin. – M.: Politizdat, 1986. - 399 s.
18. Fuko M. Rozhdenie biopolitiki. Kurs lekciy, prochitannyh v Kollezh de Frans v 1978-1979 uch. godu / Per. s fr. A.V. D'yakova / M. Fuko. - SPb.: Nauka, 2010. - 447 s.
19. Yudin B.G. Bioetika: principy, pravila, problemy / B.G. Yudin. – M.: Editorial URSS, 1998. - 470 s.
20. Annas G. American bioethics / G. Annas. - Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2005. - 274 r.
21. BeauchampT.L. Principles of biomedical ethics / T.L Beauchamp, J.F. Childress. - 8th ed. (with notes) - Oxford; Oxford Univ. Rress, 2019. - 496 p.
22. Daniels N. Equity and Population Health: Towards a Broader Bioethics / N. Daniels. - Agenda en Hastings Center Report, 2006. - Vol. 36(4) – P. 22-35.
